US courtroom docket affirms Chinese firm’s $70m arbitration award

Treaty violation: Like France, US   courtroom docket  affirms Chinese firm's $70m arbitration award   in opposition to  Nigeria



An   enchantment  courtroom docket  withinside the  United States (US) has   permitted  Zhongshan Fucheng Industrial Investment Co. Ltd. to   put into effect  the $70 million arbitration award   in opposition to  Nigeria.

In a 2-1 verdict   added  on August 9,   the bulk  ruling affirmed the judgment of   the United States  district   courtroom docket  for the district of Columbia that held that the arbitration award is enforceable.

In January 2023, Beryl Howell, the presiding   choose  of the   decrease  courtroom docket ,   brushed off  Nigeria's argument that the   courtroom docket  did   now no longer  have jurisdiction over the case   because the  usa  is a sovereign entity.

Howell held that the   courtroom docket  has jurisdiction   because the  United Kingdom (UK),   in which  the $70 million arbitration award   turned into  issued   in opposition to  Nigeria, is a signatory to the New York Convention.


ZHONGSHAN FUCHENG VS NIGERIA

In 2010, Zhongshan,   thru  Zhuhai Zhongfu Industrial Group Co. Ltd. (Zhuhai), its Chinese   discern  business enterprise ,   obtained  rights to   increase  a   loose  change  region  in Ogun   nation .

A   yr  later, Zhongshan   installation  Zhongfu International Investment (NIG) FZE (Zhongfu), a Nigerian entity, to   control  the   undertaking  below  the permission of the Ogun   nation  authorities .

However,   matters  took a   exceptional  flip  in July 2016   whilst  the investor accused the   nation  authorities  of   all at once  shifting  to terminate its appointment   even as  trying to  set up  a brand new  supervisor  for the   loose  change  region .

Subsequently, Zhongfu initiated an   funding  treaty arbitration   in opposition to  Nigeria   below  the bilateral   funding  treaty   among  the People's Republic of China and Nigeria (the China-Nigeria BIT).

The arbitrators had   dominated  that Nigeria   turned into  in breach of its   duties  below  the China-Nigeria BIT and   provided  Zhongshan   reimbursement  of around $70 million.

In January 2022, the Chinese   business enterprise  initiated a case to   are trying to find  enforcement of the arbitration award.

Nigeria pleaded   nation  immunity   however  turned into  became  away   via way of means of  Sara Cockerill, a   excessive  courtroom docket  choose  withinside the  UK, who   stated  the   usa  abused   the time-frame  for   attractive  arbitral awards.


THE US APPEAL COURT JUDGMENT

In   the bulk  judgment,   the United States  appellant   courtroom docket  held that the   very last  arbitration award is enforceable   below  the New York   conference  because the  dispute is   among  "persons" that   proportion  a   felony  business  relationship.

The   courtroom docket  dominated  that the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) arbitration exception stripped Nigeria of the sovereign immunity   withinside the  arbitration award case.

"For the foregoing reasons, we   preserve  that the   very last  award is enforceable   below  the New York   conference  as it  arose out of   variations  among  'persons' that   proportion  a   felony ,   business  relationship,"   the bulk  judgment reads.

"The district   courtroom docket  consequently  has jurisdiction over   this example  below  the FSIA's arbitration exception.



The judgment of the district   courtroom docket  is affirmed."

The majority judgment   became  issued   through  Patricia Millett and Julianna Childs.

In the dissenting judgment, Gregory Katsas, the   0.33  judge, argued   that after  the New York   conference  became  drafted, the word "persons" did   now no longer  encompass  a sovereign nation.

Katsas held that the   movement  of Ogun   nation  can't  be attributed to Nigeria,   including  that the arbitration award "arises   entirely  out of Nigeria's sovereign acts   ruled  through  public   global  law".

"Text,   prison  context, and drafting   records  all   suggest  that the word 'persons,' as used   withinside the  New York Convention, does   now no longer  encompass  signatory   international locations  appearing  as sovereigns. I respectfully dissent," Katsas said.

NIGERIA LOSING CASE AGAINST CHINESE FIRMS IN MULTIPLE JURISDICTIONS

Barely   3  days after the judgment of   the United States  enchantment  courtroom docket , a Paris   courtroom docket  in France ordered the seizure of   3  jets belonging to the Nigerian   authorities  over the dispute   regarding  the arbitration award to the Chinese firms.

In 2023, a   courtroom docket  of   enchantment  withinside the  UK   dominated  that Nigeria is   accountable for  a $70 million arbitration award in favour of the Chinese   company .

The   improvement  manner  that Nigeria has   misplaced  arbitration award   instances  towards  the Chinese   company  in France,   the United States , and the UK.

The Nigerian   authorities  has accused the Chinese   company  of   trying to  use   misleading  manner  to   gather  the country's offshore assets.

[attachment deleted by admin]